540 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN 46202

Single Family Detached MLS #: 22021676 Courtesy Of Keller Williams Indianapolis Metro North

$599,900

3 beds | 2 baths | 1 half baths | 2,222 sq ft
Print property details Share
Estimated monthly payments: $2,622/mo.* (recalculate)

Property InformationDescription

Nestled in the heart of historic Lockerbie Square, this beautifully preserved home effortlessly blends old-world charm with contemporary comforts. Perfectly situated just blocks from downtown Indianapolis' sports venues, concert halls, and vibrant entertainment scene, this home offers an unbeatable location. Thoughtfully updated while maintaining its character, this gem offers the perfect balance of elegance and functionality. Step into the bright, remodeled kitchen featuring stunning quartz countertops, brand-new cabinetry, and sleek stainless steel appliances. The adjacent formal dining and living rooms are separated by original hardwood pocket doors, adding a touch of historic grandeur. Large windows flood the home with natural light, creating an inviting and airy ambiance throughout. Downstairs, a versatile multi-purpose room adapts to your needs-ideal as a home office, library, or den-along with a convenient half bath. Throughout the home, you'll find exquisite details like stained-glass windows and exposed brick, adding warmth and personality. The elegant hardwood staircase leads to the second level, where three spacious bedrooms, two full baths, and a laundry room await. The owner's suite is a true retreat, boasting dual closets, a cozy sitting area, and a fully renovated en suite with a beautifully tiled shower. The second full bath features a tiled shower, a separate soaking tub, and a double vanity for added convenience. Whether you're searching for a full-time residence or a charming downtown retreat, this is a must-see!

Features

  • Age: Over 50 Years Old
  • Appliances: Dishwasher, Oven - Gas, Range, Refrigerator, Washer
  • Architecture Style: Other
  • Heating System: Forced Air
  • Lot Size: 0.11 Acres
  • Rooms: Basement, Dining Room, Kitchen, Living Room, Office
  • View Type: City

MAP & DIRECTIONS

Get Directions
540 E New York Street, Indianapolis, IN 46202
View Directions

School Information

540 E New York Street, Indianapolis, IN 46202

Elementary School
Grades PK-8 | Public School
IPS BUTLER UNIVERSITY LABORATORY SCHOOL 60
Indianapolis, IN 46205
3330 N Pennsylvania St
317.­226.4369
Distance: 3.2 mi
School Rating
C-
Student:Teacher Ratio
12:1
Total Students
585
Elementary School
Grades KG-8 | Public School
CENTER FOR INQUIRY SCHOOL 2
Indianapolis, IN 46202
725 N New Jersey St
317.­226.4202
Distance: 0.4 mi
School Rating
C+
Student:Teacher Ratio
11:1
Total Students
438
Elementary School
Grades PK-8 | Public School
FRANCIS PARKER MONTESSORI SCHOOL 56
Indianapolis, IN 46205
2353 Columbia Ave
317.­226.4256
Distance: 2.1 mi
School Rating
D+
Student:Teacher Ratio
8:1
Total Students
346
Elementary School
Grades PK-8 | Public School
URBAN ACT ACADEMY SCHOOL 14
Indianapolis, IN 46202
1250 E Market St
317.­226.4414
Distance: 0.6 mi
School Rating
D-
Student:Teacher Ratio
14:1
Total Students
321
Middle School
Grades PK-8 | Public School
IPS BUTLER UNIVERSITY LABORATORY SCHOOL 60
Indianapolis, IN 46205
3330 N Pennsylvania St
317.­226.4369
Distance: 3.2 mi
School Rating
C-
Student:Teacher Ratio
12:1
Total Students
585
Middle School
Grades KG-8 | Public School
CENTER FOR INQUIRY SCHOOL 2
Indianapolis, IN 46202
725 N New Jersey St
317.­226.4202
Distance: 0.4 mi
School Rating
C+
Student:Teacher Ratio
11:1
Total Students
438
Middle School
Grades PK-8 | Public School
FRANCIS PARKER MONTESSORI SCHOOL 56
Indianapolis, IN 46205
2353 Columbia Ave
317.­226.4256
Distance: 2.1 mi
School Rating
D+
Student:Teacher Ratio
8:1
Total Students
346
Middle School
Grades PK-8 | Public School
URBAN ACT ACADEMY SCHOOL 14
Indianapolis, IN 46202
1250 E Market St
317.­226.4414
Distance: 0.6 mi
School Rating
D-
Student:Teacher Ratio
14:1
Total Students
321
High School
Grades 9-12 | Public School
PURDUE POLYTECHNIC HIGH SCHOOL
Indianapolis, IN 46225
525 S Meridian St Ste Lla
317.­832.1200
Distance: 1.0 mi
School Rating
D-
Student:Teacher Ratio
22:1
Total Students
543
High School
Grades 9-12 | Public School
ARSENAL TECHNICAL HIGH SCHOOL
Indianapolis, IN 46201
1500 E Michigan St
317.­693.5300
Distance: 0.7 mi
School Rating
F
Student:Teacher Ratio
10:1
Total Students
2103
High School
Grades 9-12 | Public School
CRISPUS ATTUCKS HIGH SCHOOL
Indianapolis, IN 46202
1140 Dr Martin Luther King Jr St
317.­226.2800
Distance: 1.4 mi
School Rating
F
Student:Teacher Ratio
10:1
Total Students
1157
High School
Grades 9-12 | Public School
GEORGE WASHINGTON HIGH SCHOOL
Indianapolis, IN 46222
2215 W Washington St
317.­693.5555
Distance: 2.8 mi
School Rating
F
Student:Teacher Ratio
9:1
Total Students
798
High School
Grades 9-12 | Public School
SHORTRIDGE HIGH SCHOOL
Indianapolis, IN 46208
3401 N Meridian St
317.­226.2810
Distance: 3.3 mi
School Rating
D
Student:Teacher Ratio
9:1
Total Students
1077
Other Nearby Schools Distance Type Grades School Rating
Holy Cross Central School 0.7 mi Private KG-8
Paramount Cottage Home 0.7 mi Public KG-4 A
Lumen Christi Catholic School 0.9 mi Private PK-12
Legacy Learning Center 0.9 mi Private PK-12
Longfellow Stem Magnet Middle School 1.0 mi Public 7-8 C+
H. L. Harshman Magnet Middle School 1.0 mi Public 7-8 D+
Theodore Potter Magnet Elementary School 74 1.1 mi Public KG-6 D+
William Mckinley Elementary School 39 1.3 mi Public PK-6 B-
Herron High School 1.3 mi Public 9-12 A
The Oaks Academy 1.3 mi Private 6-8
Thomas D. Gregg Elementary School 15 1.4 mi Public PK-6 C
Center For Inquiry School 27 1.4 mi Public PK-8 D+
Trinity Christian School 1.5 mi Private PK-12
Emmaus Lutheran School 1.6 mi Private PK-8
Se Neighborhood School Of Excellence 1.8 mi Public KG-8 D+
This information is provided for general informational purposes only and should not be relied on in making any home-buying decisions. School information does not guarantee enrollment. Contact a local real estate professional or the school district(s) for current information on schools. This information is not intended for use in determining a person's eligibility to attend a school or to use or benefit from other city, town or local services.

Demographic Data

Indianapolis, IN 46202

Median Age: 32.3
Married: 20%
Number of Households: 11,155
Households with Children: 9%
  • Occupancy Types
    • 0 Vacant
    • 0 Owned
    • 0 Rented
  • Transportation to Work
    • 0 Drive
    • 0 Public Transportation
    • 0 Walk / Bike / Other
    • 0 Work at Home
Copyright © 2025 MIBOR Service Corporation. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. Information being provided is for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.